Quantcast
ZME Science
  • News
  • Environment
  • Health
  • Future
  • Space
  • Features
    Menu
    Natural Sciences
    Health
    History & Humanities
    Space & Astronomy
    Technology
    Culture
    Resources
    Natural Sciences

    Physics

    • Matter and Energy
    • Quantum Mechanics
    • Thermodynamics

    Chemistry

    • Periodic Table
    • Applied Chemistry
    • Materials
    • Physical Chemistry

    Biology

    • Anatomy
    • Biochemistry
    • Ecology
    • Genetics
    • Microbiology
    • Plants and Fungi

    Geology and Paleontology

    • Planet Earth
    • Earth Dynamics
    • Rocks and Minerals
    • Volcanoes
    • Dinosaurs
    • Fossils

    Animals

    • Mammals
    • Birds
    • Fish
    • Reptiles
    • Amphibians
    • Invertebrates
    • Pets
    • Conservation
    • Animals Facts

    Climate and Weather

    • Climate Change
    • Weather and Atmosphere

    Geography

    Mathematics

    Health
    • Drugs
    • Diseases and Conditions
    • Human Body
    • Mind and Brain
    • Food and Nutrition
    • Wellness
    History & Humanities
    • Anthropology
    • Archaeology
    • Economics
    • History
    • People
    • Sociology
    Space & Astronomy
    • The Solar System
    • The Sun
    • The Moon
    • Planets
    • Asteroids, Meteors and Comets
    • Astronomy
    • Astrophysics
    • Cosmology
    • Exoplanets and Alien Life
    • Spaceflight and Exploration
    Technology
    • Computer Science & IT
    • Engineering
    • Inventions
    • Sustainability
    • Renewable Energy
    • Green Living
    Culture
    • Culture and Society
    • Bizarre Stories
    • Lifestyle
    • Art and Music
    • Gaming
    • Books
    • Movies and Shows
    Resources
    • How To
    • Science Careers
    • Metascience
    • Fringe Science
    • Science Experiments
    • School and Study
    • Natural Sciences
    • Health
    • History and Humanities
    • Space & Astronomy
    • Culture
    • Technology
    • Resources
  • Reviews
  • More
    • Agriculture
    • Anthropology
    • Biology
    • Chemistry
    • Electronics
    • Geology
    • History
    • Mathematics
    • Nanotechnology
    • Economics
    • Paleontology
    • Physics
    • Psychology
    • Robotics
  • About Us
    • About
    • The Team
    • Advertise
    • Contribute
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
ZME Science

No Result
View All Result
ZME Science

Home → Science

Did human hands evolved to pack a punch?

We humans arguably came to dominate the world thanks to our dexterous hands, which allow gripping tools and manipulating objects. An eccentric professor at University of Utah agrees, but with a twist. According to David Carrier there's a secondary evolutionary driver that led our hands to reach their current shape and dexterity: fist punching. To illustrate his hypothesis, Carrier turned to a macabre experiment in which cadaver hands clenched in various positions, from open hand to a good old sucker punch fist, were bashed against a dumbbell. Carrier showed that a fist could handle the strike with double the force supported by an open hand before bones started to break.

Tibi Puiu by Tibi Puiu
February 15, 2019
in Science

We humans arguably came to dominate the world thanks to our dexterous hands, which allow gripping tools and manipulating objects. An eccentric professor at University of Utah agrees, but with a twist. According to David Carrier there’s a secondary evolutionary driver that led our hands to reach their current shape and dexterity: fist punching. To illustrate his hypothesis, Carrier turned to a macabre experiment in which cadaver hands clenched in various positions, from open hand to a good old sucker punch fist, were bashed against a dumbbell. Carrier showed that a fist could handle the strike with double the force supported by an open hand before bones started to break.

Muscles were contracted by guitar pegs, and a pendulum was used to swing the punch. Image: Andre Mossman/University of Utah
Muscles were contracted by guitar pegs, and a pendulum was used to swing the punch. Image: Andre Mossman/University of Utah

More precisely, fishing wires were attached to the forearm’s tendons, then strapped to a guitar tuner at the other end. By turning the tuner, Carrier and colleagues could flex and position the individual fingers of the hand into any position. They settled for three positions:  clenched fist, loose fist or an open palm. The hands were put on a platform, then a pendulum swung the fists into a dumbbell. Force sensors were attached to both arm and dumbbell. Apparently, the strain on the  metacarpals was vastly reduced in a clenched fist position, compared to any of the other two.

“This is relatively strong evidence that there is a performance advantage,” Prof Carrier said.

“Whether or not natural selection ever acted on that advantage is something we can’t answer directly. But at the same time, given this evidence, you can’t argue that selection on aggressive fighting behaviour was not relevant.”

Of course, that’s not to say that Carrier disagrees with the overwhelming consensus: that hand evolution was shaped by tool use. Rather, he posits that fist fighting  “has to be included on the list of possible factors that could have influenced the evolution of the hand”.

Humans can safely strike under a clenched fist with 55% more force than with an open hand. Image: David Carrier/University of Utah
Humans can safely strike under a clenched fist with 55% more force than with an open hand. Image: David Carrier/University of Utah

Carrier says that no other primate can make a fist, and has at one time even gone as far as saying the human face also evolved to take a punch better. Actually, this isn’t the first time he’s tested this hypothesis. Back in 2012, ZME Science reported how Carrier devised an experiment in which different martial artists hit a punching bag, and found the structure of the fist provides additional support for the knuckles to transmit punching force. Again, he didn’t thought this was some evolutionary coincidence. His ideas are controversial. His experiments even more so, but he seems to be making an interesting point at least.

Most scientists aren’t convinced, though. Speaking for the Washington Post, Arizona State University’s Mary Marzke said:

“It also is surprising that the authors compared fist-punching with palm-slapping, instead of with striking by the heel of the palm,” Marzke told The Post. “The latter is well known to be very effective in fighting. It has the advantage of concentrating force over a relatively small area of the hand, an advantage that the author highlighted for the fist in an earlier study. The palm heel punch does not require hominin thumb and finger proportions.”

“At best, pugilistic encounters as an explanation for the evolution of the human hand remains just another story. There are many other behaviors that could be marshaled to explain the morphology of human hand bones,” said Brigitte Demes of Stony Brook University.

Speaking for the BBC, Dr Tracy Kimmel, a palaeoanthropologist at the University of Kent, acknowledged that Carrier’s work is sound, technically speaking, but the findings can’t support the hypothesis. Instead, she argues that there’s strong evidence that  our hands evolved to manipulate tools, considering “fossil evidence of tools goes back more than three millions years, and aligns with changes to hominid anatomy.” Everything else, is secondary.

Was this helpful?


Thanks for your feedback!

Related posts:
  1. Hands and digits evolved from fish fins, groundbreaking study proves
  2. A history of computer science, from punch cards to virtual reality
  3. Early human ancestors used their hands much in the way as we do
  4. Sugar worsens high-fat diets through one-two punch
  5. Climate change and land use are lethal one-two punch for protected areas
Tags: evolutionfisthand

ADVERTISEMENT
  • News
  • Environment
  • Health
  • Future
  • Space
  • Features
  • Reviews
  • More
  • About Us

© 2007-2021 ZME Science - Not exactly rocket science. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Environment
  • Health
  • Future
  • Space
  • Features
    • Natural Sciences
    • Health
    • History and Humanities
    • Space & Astronomy
    • Culture
    • Technology
    • Resources
  • Reviews
  • More
    • Agriculture
    • Anthropology
    • Biology
    • Chemistry
    • Electronics
    • Geology
    • History
    • Mathematics
    • Nanotechnology
    • Economics
    • Paleontology
    • Physics
    • Psychology
    • Robotics
  • About Us
    • About
    • The Team
    • Advertise
    • Contribute
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact

© 2007-2021 ZME Science - Not exactly rocket science. All Rights Reserved.

Don’t you want to get smarter every day?

YES, sign me up!

Over 35,000 subscribers can’t be wrong. Don’t worry, we never spam. By signing up you agree to our privacy policy.

✕
ZME Science News

FREE
VIEW