In a room filled with oil & gas executives, a veteran lobbyist called Richard Berman held a crash course on how companies can use scare tactics and manipulation to make environmental groups look like radical morons. This includes digging up dirt on opponents (celebrities are the focus), exploiting basic emotions like fear and anger, skewing information and other dirty tactics, because in the end “you can either win ugly or lose pretty,” Berman said. Of course, these things would have never been admitted in public, but unbeknownst to Berman the whole meeting was taped by one of the executives who found the whole affair appalling, then made public by the New York Times.
Richard “Rick” Berman is well known in Washington, being a PR specialist and long time lobbyst operating through his consulting firm, Berman and Company, Inc. In the past couple of years he’s been involved with almost 50 campaigns lobbying for powerful interest against environmental groups. Some of these campaigns include “PETA kills animals” ( smears People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals and promotes negative information about the group’s practices), “Stepup Wyoming” (attacks Wyoming’s teachers union and advocates for anti-union legislation), “NO Drink Taxi” ( opposes federal, state, and local attempts to increase taxes on alcohol), “Minimum Wage” (opposes all federal, state, and local efforts to raise the minimum wage, and promotes misinformation about the consequences of minimum-wage increases), “EPA Facts” (disparages the Environmental Protection Agency and claims that environmental regulations will hurt the economy), and many other shady and distasteful attempts to manipulate the public.
At the meeting in Washington, sponsored by Western Energy Alliance, a group whose members include Devon Energy, Halliburton and Anadarko Petroleum, Berman was trying to raise cash (a measly $3 million) for his latest attack: “Big Green Radicals”. Let’s take a look at the first introductory paragraph posted on the campaign’s website (biggreenradicals.com):
“Environmental activist groups have lobbied for stronger laws to protect the environment and public health since the 19th century. But while these organizations started out curbing real threats to our safety and the future of our planet, they have morphed into multi-million dollar lobbying machines that use questionable tactics to scare the American public and policymakers into supporting unnecessary and unreasonable policies.”
This message is turning really old, really fast. Just like in the case of Berman previous campaigns he’s using an old trick: just take what the other side is saying and pin it on them instead. Of course, Berman has other tricks as well, as he revealed at the meeting where he schooled the oil execs on what PR is all about (full transcript of the meeting).
How to smear labor rights
…we’ll take the labor unions for example. I am well known for going after the labor unions for a thousand different reasons. And people say, “Well, what’s your offense?” I say, “I get up every morning and I try and figure out how to screw with the labor unions. That’s my offense.”
How to kill minimum wage
We’re not experts and so you don’t want them [the general public] trying to be experts. But if you put enough information out there and say, “Well it could go to $10.10, but you could also lose a lot of jobs, the Congressional Budget Office says you can lose a lot of jobs.” And again, we got a lot of ads on this thing.
You get in people’s mind[sic] a tie. They don’t know who is right. And you get all ties because the tie basically insures the status quo.
How to use repetition to buildup common knowledge
That’s common knowledge. And that comes from people hearing something enough times from enough different places, people repeating it to each other, that you reach a point where you have solidified your position.
If we can solidify the position on drilling, fracking, etc. We have achieved something the other side cannot overcome because it’s very tough to break common knowledge.
It’s very tough to break first opinions. You know the guy that gets to make the first opinion, the first impression, has a huge advantage because people don’t want to admit they were wrong the first time
How to get things viral
“If you want a video to go viral, have kids or animals,” he said, and then he showed a spot his company had prepared using schoolchildren as participants in a mock union election — to suggest that union bosses do not have real elections.
“Use humor to minimize or marginalize the people on the other side,” he added.
How to manipulate public judgement
…And so we put this ad in the New York Times, and basically said, “Hey, you ought to be concerned about the health care bill.” But, we didn’t really say “why”. All we said is “seniors might have to pay more money”, or “your premiums might go up”, but there wasn’t any fact here. So this is an attempt at creating public opinion about something. Kind of soft top-line.
How oil companies can stay safe from public scrutiny
People always ask me one question all the time: ‘How do I know that I won’t be found out as a supporter of what you’re doing?’ ” Mr. Berman told the crowd. “We run all of this stuff through nonprofit organizations that are insulated from having to disclose donors. There is total anonymity. People don’t know who supports us.
How to use hate and anger to your advantage
Anger is what people have over something that has happened. Fear is what people have when they have when they think something might happen. It’s when you tell people, “Be careful of what you wish for. The law of unintended consequences. This might happen even though you don’t want it to happen.”
Fear and anger have to be part of this campaign. If you want to win, that’s what we’re going to do. We’re not going to get people to like the oil and gas industry over the next few months.
There is no sympathy for the oil and gas industry. So we’re not going to tap into the sympathetic, “Oh, I’m sympathetic for all those poor guys who are running the energy companies.”
How to attack celebrities who are against corporate fossil fuel agenda
“There is nothing the public likes more than tearing down celebrities and playing up the hypocrisy angle”
Concerning the hypocrisy angle, here are some of the ads Berman is currently running.
Another video ad is centered on Leonardo DiCaprio, famous Hollywood actor who has donated tens of millions to environmental projects. But he’s a hypocrite too. He didn’t even win an Oscar (failure), but thinks he’s better than any of us. Needless to say, the whole video is pathetic; a collage of scenes from DiCaprio’s movie and a completely out of context shot from DiCaprio’s UN speech meant to convey the same message: “Look at this prick! He’s trying to save freaking whales, but he owns a yacht!” The natural reaction (if this is what you’re thinking already and just needed some support) follows: people like DiCaprio, and all environmental activists by association, are spoiled radicals or anarchists.
Then there’s the most pathetic ad of them all (and Berman has a few).
So, what we’re seeing is a typical environmental meeting staged in a garage (broke losers). Tonight’s hearing is about fracking, after last time they debated whether or not the moon was made of cheese (lunatics). Then, the discussion quickly escalates: i think fracking makes me fat (preposterous link – they have no idea what they’re talking about), “oh, i used the gogal last night to research fracking” (another moron who reads environmental propaganda on the internet), “lately, Mr. Snuggles won’t even give me a kiss at bedtime! I know fracking has something to do with it”, cries the group retard (no comment). Then the second part: data, numbers, people in suits working on important stuff. These are real professionals. “EPA says fracking is safe” and “[whatever study] says banning fracking will cost 68,000 jobs!” Coloradans should listen to the experts.
Working on something shady? Doesn’t matter if your products or services are a health hazard to the public. Berman’s your man! There’s no corporate interest in the detriment of common people that he won’t take on, for the right price. But really, it’s easy to pin him as the poster boy of all that is evil, we shouldn’t forget though that he’s only a proxy. Not all oil execs are bad guys (some say), but a lot of them hire people like Berman to do their dirty work. And they should be ashamed of themselves.
Enjoyed this article? Join 40,000+ subscribers to the ZME Science newsletter. Subscribe now!