ZME Science
No Result
View All Result
ZME Science
No Result
View All Result
ZME Science

Home → Science → News

Bad scientists use puzzling jargon to mask wrongdoings

Weeding out bad science is an extremely complicated and delicate process, and short of peer review there's little left to do; even peer review is flawed, or at the very least imperfect.

Mihai AndreibyMihai Andrei
November 19, 2015
in News, Science
A A
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterSubmit to Reddit

RelatedPosts

Immune cells from the common cold offer protection against COVID-19, researchers find
Art-integrated science lessons make some students ‘learn at 105%’, new study finds
Masks made of ostrich cells make COVID-19 glow in the dark
Author of Gay Marriage Study Admits to Lies

The pressure on scientists is without a doubt stronger than ever; in an environment with ever growing competition, you simply have to publish all the time and constantly make breakthroughs, sometimes up to inhuman levels. This environment, often call “publish or perish” is starting to take its toll on the quality of science, as more and more researchers publish incomplete or sometimes misleading findings – with some authors even falsifying their data.

Image via Flickr.

But weeding out bad science is an extremely complicated and delicate process, and short of peer review there’s little left to do; even peer review is flawed, or at the very least imperfect. The best thing we have is peer review, and that has some pretty big flaws, so researchers have developed a new way of finding fraudulent papers: the “obfuscation index”.

“We believe the underlying idea behind obfuscation is to muddle the truth,” said one of the team, David Markowitz. “Scientists faking data know that they are committing a misconduct and do not want to get caught. Therefore, one strategy to evade this may be to obscure parts of the paper. We suggest that language can be one of many variables to differentiate between fraudulent and genuine science.”

In other words, when scientists want to mask something, they use big words – scientific jargon – hoping to puzzle people (or why not, bore them) enough that their shortcomings are overlooked. In order to test this theory Jeff Hancock, a professor of communication at Stanford, and graduate student David Markowitz searched the archives of PubMed, a database of life sciences journals, from 1973 to 2013 for retracted papers. They found a total of 253 scientific papers retracted for fraud in the four decades, and compared them to unretracted papers from the same period to see what stands out.

They found that fraudulent papers use significantly more jargon than regular ones:

“Fradulent papers had about 60 more jargon-like words per paper compared to unretracted papers,” Markowitz said. “This is a non-trivial amount.”

Of course, just because someone uses more complicated language doesn’t mean there is something wrong with their research, but in the future, a computerized algorithm could tag these and label them for additional investigation. This approach is just in its initial stages though.

“Science fraud is of increasing concern in academia, and automatic tools for identifying fraud might be useful,” Hancock said. “But much more research is needed before considering this kind of approach. Obviously, there is a very high error rate that would need to be improved, but also science is based on trust, and introducing a ‘fraud detection’ tool into the publication process might undermine that trust.”

 

Tags: journalpeer reviewScience

ShareTweetShare
Mihai Andrei

Mihai Andrei

Dr. Andrei Mihai is a geophysicist and founder of ZME Science. He has a Ph.D. in geophysics and archaeology and has completed courses from prestigious universities (with programs ranging from climate and astronomy to chemistry and geology). He is passionate about making research more accessible to everyone and communicating news and features to a broad audience.

Related Posts

Economics

The US wants to know if researchers in other countries follow MAGA doctrine

byMihai Andrei
4 months ago
Economics

Trump’s War on Science Is Fueling a Brain Drain in Real Time

byMihai Andrei
4 months ago
News

Scientists slam American Society for Microbiology for taking down features of non-white researchers

byMihai Andrei
6 months ago
News

Over 70% of science award finalists in the US are children of immigrants

byMihai Andrei
10 months ago

Recent news

Scientists Discover Life Finds a Way in the Deepest, Darkest Trenches on Earth

July 31, 2025

Solid-State Batteries Charge in 3 Minutes, Offer Nearly Double the Range, and Never Catch Fire. So Why Aren’t They In Your Phones and Cars Yet?

July 30, 2025

What if the Secret to Sustainable Cities Was Buried in Roman Cement?

July 30, 2025
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Editorial Policy
  • Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
  • How we review products
  • Contact

© 2007-2025 ZME Science - Not exactly rocket science. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Science News
  • Environment
  • Health
  • Space
  • Future
  • Features
    • Natural Sciences
    • Physics
      • Matter and Energy
      • Quantum Mechanics
      • Thermodynamics
    • Chemistry
      • Periodic Table
      • Applied Chemistry
      • Materials
      • Physical Chemistry
    • Biology
      • Anatomy
      • Biochemistry
      • Ecology
      • Genetics
      • Microbiology
      • Plants and Fungi
    • Geology and Paleontology
      • Planet Earth
      • Earth Dynamics
      • Rocks and Minerals
      • Volcanoes
      • Dinosaurs
      • Fossils
    • Animals
      • Mammals
      • Birds
      • Fish
      • Amphibians
      • Reptiles
      • Invertebrates
      • Pets
      • Conservation
      • Animal facts
    • Climate and Weather
      • Climate change
      • Weather and atmosphere
    • Health
      • Drugs
      • Diseases and Conditions
      • Human Body
      • Mind and Brain
      • Food and Nutrition
      • Wellness
    • History and Humanities
      • Anthropology
      • Archaeology
      • History
      • Economics
      • People
      • Sociology
    • Space & Astronomy
      • The Solar System
      • Sun
      • The Moon
      • Planets
      • Asteroids, meteors & comets
      • Astronomy
      • Astrophysics
      • Cosmology
      • Exoplanets & Alien Life
      • Spaceflight and Exploration
    • Technology
      • Computer Science & IT
      • Engineering
      • Inventions
      • Sustainability
      • Renewable Energy
      • Green Living
    • Culture
    • Resources
  • Videos
  • Reviews
  • About Us
    • About
    • The Team
    • Advertise
    • Contribute
    • Editorial policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact

© 2007-2025 ZME Science - Not exactly rocket science. All Rights Reserved.