ZME Science
No Result
View All Result
ZME Science
No Result
View All Result
ZME Science

Home → Science

Whoopsie: US cities under-reported their emissions by almost 20%, study shows

A different method came up with a very different figure.

Fermin KoopbyFermin Koop
February 3, 2021
in Climate, Environment, News, Science
A A
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterSubmit to Reddit

Cities across the United States are largely underestimating their carbon dioxide emissions, a new study claims. Researchers compared self-reported data from 48 cities against a new measurement system of fossil fuel emissions and found the urban centers under-reported their emissions by almost 20%.

The city of Cleveland. Image credit: Flickr / Chris Capell

Almost three-quarters of fossil fuel carbon dioxide emissions, the most important anthropogenic greenhouse gas, come from cities. Projections show cities could add over two billion people this century with global urban areas tripling by 2030, highlighting need for urgent action (and in truth, some cities are already working in that direction).

Just like countries, cities also track (or rather, estimate) of their own greenhouse gas emissions. But researchers have raised doubts over them due to a lack of systematic and peer-reviewed assessment of their quality or accuracy. With this in mind, a team at Northern Arizona University decided to take a closer look.

They compared the greenhouse gas inventories of 48 cities in the US with their automated measurement system known as Vulcan, which can estimate fossil-fuel emissions at specific geographic points and over large areas. The group of cities account for 13.7% of US urban emissions and 17.7% of US urban population.

The comparison showed large discrepancies between what cities said they emitted and what they actually do. Self-reported emissions were 18.3% below the emissions estimated by the Vulcan system. But that average doesn’t tell the whole story. For example, Cleveland, Ohio reported emissions 90.1% below the Vulcan estimate while Palo Alto, California, reported emissions 41.7% greater.

The researchers said the differences can be explained by cities omitting petroleum fuel use and point source emissions in the industrial/commercial sector. Sometimes they also use different accounting perspectives on marine shipping and airborne emissions and different methods in on-road emission estimation, they added.

“I don’t think there’s any attempt to systematically or intentionally underestimate emissions,” Kevin Gurney, the lead author of the study, said in a statement. Although some cities correctly estimated their emissions, he noted, though “whether that’s right for the right reasons or right for the wrong reasons, it’s difficult to know.”

Accuracy and precision are critical to estimating emissions, whether reported by a city, state, or country, the researchers wrote. If US cities are under-reporting their emissions by so much, this essentially means that the entire country is also under-reporting.

RelatedPosts

Europeans don’t believe climate change deniers and want governments to take action, huge poll reveals
How climate change will shape New York City in the next 100 years
Carbon emissions threaten to destroy pink salmon population
As Trump alienates the US from the rest of the world, California Gov. takes up climate talks with China

While the authors note that their results raise “serious concerns” about cities’ self-reported approach to quantify emissions, they also added that work is being done to build a better emissions quantification system. It would calibrate emissions information for all cities in collaboration with local authorities, leaving urban climate experts more time to focus on coming up with the best mitigation strategies.

Hundreds of cities across the US have pledged to greatly reduce their greenhouse gas emissions but many are struggling to meet their targets. A study last year looked at the country’s 100 most populous cities and found only 45 set specific targets for cutting emissions during the past decade. Of those, two-thirds were falling behind on their targets.

Newly sworn-in US President Joe Biden has pledged to decarbonize the country’s economy by 2050, in line with the goals of the 2015 Paris Agreement on climate change. Former President Donald Trump decided to the US would leave the climate accord, but Biden reversed the move as soon as he took office last month.

Tags: climate changeemissions

ShareTweetShare
Fermin Koop

Fermin Koop

Fermin Koop is a reporter from Buenos Aires, Argentina. He holds an MSc from Reading University (UK) on Environment and Development and is specialized in environment and climate change news.

Related Posts

Climate

Climate Change Unleashed a Hidden Wave That Triggered a Planetary Tremor

byMihai Andrei
2 weeks ago
Champiñón Hongos Naturaleza Setas Reino Fungi
Animal facts

What do Fungi, Chameleons, and Humans All Have in Common? We’re all Heterotrophs

byShiella Olimpos
4 weeks ago
Climate

Climate Change Is Rewriting America’s Gardening Map and Some Plants Can’t Keep Up

byGrace van Deelen
1 month ago
Climate

Scientists Create “Bait” to Lure Baby Corals Back to Dying Reefs

byMihai Andrei
2 months ago

Recent news

China Resurrected an Abandoned Soviet ‘Sea Monster’ That’s Part Airplane, Part Hovercraft

June 30, 2025
great white shark

This Shark Expert Has Spent Decades Studying Attacks and Says We’ve Been Afraid for the Wrong Reasons

June 30, 2025

A Rocket Carried Cannabis Seeds and 166 Human Remains into Space But Their Capsule Never Made It Back

June 30, 2025
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Editorial Policy
  • Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
  • How we review products
  • Contact

© 2007-2025 ZME Science - Not exactly rocket science. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Science News
  • Environment
  • Health
  • Space
  • Future
  • Features
    • Natural Sciences
    • Physics
      • Matter and Energy
      • Quantum Mechanics
      • Thermodynamics
    • Chemistry
      • Periodic Table
      • Applied Chemistry
      • Materials
      • Physical Chemistry
    • Biology
      • Anatomy
      • Biochemistry
      • Ecology
      • Genetics
      • Microbiology
      • Plants and Fungi
    • Geology and Paleontology
      • Planet Earth
      • Earth Dynamics
      • Rocks and Minerals
      • Volcanoes
      • Dinosaurs
      • Fossils
    • Animals
      • Mammals
      • Birds
      • Fish
      • Amphibians
      • Reptiles
      • Invertebrates
      • Pets
      • Conservation
      • Animal facts
    • Climate and Weather
      • Climate change
      • Weather and atmosphere
    • Health
      • Drugs
      • Diseases and Conditions
      • Human Body
      • Mind and Brain
      • Food and Nutrition
      • Wellness
    • History and Humanities
      • Anthropology
      • Archaeology
      • History
      • Economics
      • People
      • Sociology
    • Space & Astronomy
      • The Solar System
      • Sun
      • The Moon
      • Planets
      • Asteroids, meteors & comets
      • Astronomy
      • Astrophysics
      • Cosmology
      • Exoplanets & Alien Life
      • Spaceflight and Exploration
    • Technology
      • Computer Science & IT
      • Engineering
      • Inventions
      • Sustainability
      • Renewable Energy
      • Green Living
    • Culture
    • Resources
  • Videos
  • Reviews
  • About Us
    • About
    • The Team
    • Advertise
    • Contribute
    • Editorial policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact

© 2007-2025 ZME Science - Not exactly rocket science. All Rights Reserved.