ZME Science
  • News
  • Environment
    • Animals
    • Climate
    • Renewable Energy
    • Eco tips
    • Environmental Issues
    • Green Living
  • Health
    • Alternative Medicine
    • Anatomy
    • Diseases
    • Genetics
    • Mind & Brain
    • Nutrition
  • FutureNEW
  • Space
  • Feature
    • Feature Post
    • Art
    • Great Pics
    • Design
    • Fossil Friday
    • AstroPicture
    • GeoPicture
    • Did you know?
    • Offbeat
  • More
    • About
    • The Team
    • Advertise
    • Contribute
    • Our stance on climate change
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
ZME Science

No Result
View All Result
ZME Science
No Result
View All Result
HomeScienceNews

Judges give harsher penalties when their favorite football team loses unexpectedly

We all get cranky for silly reasons sometimes, but this is a life-changing sentence we're talking about.

Mihai Andrei byMihai Andrei
July 6, 2018
inNews
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterSubmit to Reddit

A rather unusual study found that juvenile court judges in Louisiana dole out harsher sentences following an unexpected loss by the Louisiana State University football team — especially to black defendants.

We all get cranky for silly reasons, at least sometimes. Whether it’s because the bus is crowded, you didn’t get breakfast, or your favorite football team loses. That crankiness can affect us more than we’d like to admit, and they may even affect our work. However, this shouldn’t really be the case — particularly if you’re a court judge.

ADVERTISEMENT

LSU economists Ozkan Eren and Naci Mocan found a clear pattern that affects these judges’ decisions:

“Unexpected losses increase sentence lengths assigned by judges during the week following the game,” the researchers report. “Unexpected wins, or losses (in game expected to be) close contests, have no impact.”

“We find these impacts are stronger for judges who received their bachelor’s degrees from LSU,” they write, adding that these judges are thus more likely to have developed an emotional attachment to the team.

“We also find that the impact is larger for trials that take place after an upset loss in an important game” — that is, when the Associated Press ranked LSU among the top 10 teams going into the game.

The two analyzed the files for all defendants in the Louisiana juvenile justice system from 1996 to 2012, noting the severity of the sentence handed down. The decisions were then matched with the success or failure of the LSU football team (which, the researchers, note, has “an enormous group of loyal followers”) the previous weekend. They analyzed the data using a statistical method called the Las Vegas spread.

They noticed a “subtle and previously unnoticed capricious application of sentencing” whenever LSU lost unexpectedly. In other words, it wasn’t that the judges gave harsher penalties whenever LSU lost — they gave harsher penalties when they weren’t expecting to lose.

ADVERTISEMENT

Things get even more disturbing as the results also seem to have a racial component. Judges were significantly harsher on black defendants, researchers say. Note that we’re talking about juveniles.

“An upset loss increases the disposition length by about 43 days for black defendants, which translates into an increase in sentence severity by almost 8 percent,” the researchers report. “The impact of an upset loss for white defendants is about one-tenth as large—about five days.”

Many things can affect a judge’s decision, but sports results shouldn’t be one of them. However, it’s no secret that judges’ moods affect their decisions, though it hardly seems acceptable that something so trivial affects a potentially life-changing sentence.

However, researchers stress that it’s very challenging to implement strict sentencing guidelines, and this can give birth to numerous problems, but clearly, handing down sentences based on how yesterday’s game went is not how things should go. It’s not clear if a similar trend carries out in other states.

Tags: footballjudgesentence
Share52TweetShare

How much money are you losing by not going solar? Use our savings calculator for rooftop solar.

Mihai Andrei

Mihai Andrei

Andrei's background is in geophysics, and he's been fascinated by it ever since he was a child. Feeling that there is a gap between scientists and the general audience, he started ZME Science -- and the results are what you see today.

ADVERTISEMENT

EDITOR'S PICKS

Leaf blowers are not only annoying but also bad for you (and the environment)
Environment

Leaf blowers are not only annoying but also bad for you (and the environment)

by Alexandru Micu
November 15, 2019 - Updated on November 17, 2019

It comes down to the inefficient engines they use.

Read more
What are greenhouse gases and why we need to worry about them? A simple explainer

What are greenhouse gases and why we need to worry about them? A simple explainer

November 15, 2019
The difference between programming and coding with Leslie Lamport

The difference between programming and coding with Leslie Lamport

November 15, 2019
Why ketamine is so good against depression

Why ketamine is so good against depression

November 8, 2019
pixabay-brain-fog

What is brain fog: the mental fatigue that ruins your mood

October 25, 2019
ADVERTISEMENT
  • News
  • Environment
  • Health
  • Future
  • Space
  • Feature
  • More

© 2007-2019 ZME Science - Not exactly rocket science. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Environment
    • Animals
    • Climate
    • Renewable Energy
    • Eco tips
    • Environmental Issues
    • Green Living
  • Health
    • Alternative Medicine
    • Anatomy
    • Diseases
    • Genetics
    • Mind & Brain
    • Nutrition
  • Future
  • Space
  • Feature
    • Feature Post
    • Art
    • Great Pics
    • Design
    • Fossil Friday
    • AstroPicture
    • GeoPicture
    • Did you know?
    • Offbeat
  • More
    • About
    • The Team
    • Advertise
    • Contribute
    • Our stance on climate change
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact

© 2007-2019 ZME Science - Not exactly rocket science. All Rights Reserved.

Do you love science?

Join 50,000+ subscribers and get our FREE e-book on pseudoscience. 
SUBSCRIBE
close-link