Previous studies have shown that exercise seems to alleviate depression, but it was still difficult to establish a direct cause-effect relationship, which led to an interesting chicken-and-egg conundrum: does exercise really fight depression, or does depression reduce physical activity? A new study comes to settle that debate: exercise really does go a long way towards fighting depression.
Researchers at Massachusetts General Hospital have now found that people with higher levels of physical activity had lower odds of suffering from depression. Lead Researcher Karmel Choi and colleagues found that just 15 minutes of vigorous activity per day can reduce the risk of depression by 26%. Furthermore, the study found no evidence that depression affected a person’s ability to exercise.
“We found evidence that higher levels of physical activity may causally reduce risk for depression,” Dr Choi said.
“On average, doing more physical activity appears to protect against developing depression … and any activity appears to be better than none.”
The team analyzed genetic data from 611,583 adult participants, focusing on genes associated with increased physical activity, and looked at how this correlated with the risk of depression. The reasoning was that if exercise works against depression, then people more likely to do exercise would be less likely to suffer from depression — which is exactly what they observed.
These results were also confirmed with objective measurements of physical activity. Interestingly, the results only stood for objective measurements — when it came to subjective measurements, the correlation was no longer there, suggesting that people aren’t really good at self-reporting how much exercise they do.
However, when the team looked at genes that were associated with depression, these did not seem to affect the rate of physical activity. So essentially, physical activity reduces depression, but depression doesn’t necessarily reduce physical activity.
This indicates a great way of fighting the depression epidemic that is developing in the western world — but the fact that people are able to exercise doesn’t also mean they do. Finding practical ways to encourage people to work out to reduce depression is an altogether different matter.
“More work needs to be done to figure out how best to tailor recommendations to different kinds of people with different risk profiles,” Choi said.
“We currently are looking at whether and how much physical activity can benefit different at-risk groups, such as people who are genetically vulnerable to depression or those going through stressful situations. [We] hope to develop a better understanding of physical activity to promote resilience to depression.”