homehome Home chatchat Notifications


Real photo wins award in AI-generated photo competition and it's all the irony we needed

We've come full circle.

Mihai Andrei
June 14, 2024 @ 12:36 am

share Share

The flamingo photo that won bronze
F L A M I N G O N E by Miles Astray which won an AI image contest before being disqualified.

We’ve already seen stories about AI images being sent to photography and arts competitions. The algorithms have become so prolific that in some instances, the result is nigh indistinguishable from real man-made art.

But photographer Miles Astray had a different idea.

He submitted a real photography to an AI competition — the 1839 Color Photography Awards.

“I wanted to show that nature can still beat the machine and that there is still merit in real work from real creatives,” Astray tells PetaPixel over email. “After seeing recent instances of AI-generated imagery beating actual photos in competitions, I started thinking about turning the story and its implications around by submitting a real photo into an AI competition.”

The picture is a pretty surreal (but very real) image of a flamingo, hiding its head away. At first glance, you could be tricked into thinking it’s a messed-up AI image. And that’s probably also what tricked the competition judges as well — because the photo won 3rd prize in the contest. It even won the People’s Vote award.

Winners in the competition

We’re still really bad at recognizing AI images

If you’ve ever felt bad about being tricked by an AI-made image, well, it happens to everyone. The judges for this AI photography contest worked at the New York Times and Getty Images, among others. Apparently, no one figured out that the photo was real.

Astray said his experiment was successful.

“Of course, I feel bad about leading the jury astray, but I think that they are professionals who might find that this jab at AI and its ethical implications outweighs the ethical implications of deceiving the viewer, which, of course is ironic because that is what AI does.”

“I’m glad to see that this experiment confirmed my hypothesis: there is nothing more fantastic and creative than Mother Nature herself,” said Miles Astray who has no ambition to work with AI. “I don’t demonize the new technology and see its potential, but currently I see its limitations and dangers even more clearly.”

The competition organizers said they also empathize with the message of the entry, but that they still have to disqualify it.

“No one believes in the power of photography more than we do. We’ve asked Miles to work with us and give a statement for a future blog post we are going to do regarding this exact topic, with his submission, press release, and any statement he shares as a jumping-off point. As an artist, his voice will make a difference in this conversation. However, after much internal debate, we decided to disqualify his entry into the AI category in consideration of the other artists who submitted their work. Our contest categories are specifically defined to ensure fairness and clarity for all participants. Each category has distinct criteria that entrants’ images must meet.”

So where does this leave us?

We still have no reliable way of telling apart AI photography and real images. Our eyes and brains are not trustworthy for this task and other algorithms are also pretty unreliable. At the same time, we’re starting to run into AI-generated imagery more and more.

Art and photography competitions are one thing — they’re supposed to make us think. But what happens when we have AI images depicting politicians, or even our colleagues? For now, only a few algorithms can create images realistic enough to trick people, and they have safeguards, but other companies aren’t so ethical, and soon enough, we’ll be facing a deluge a of AI-generated images in our daily lives. The implications are vast and multifaceted, affecting trust, authenticity, and our perception of reality.

Nature may be unparalleled, but technology is already good enough to fool us. Who knows what implications this will have?

share Share

This EV Battery Charges in 18 Seconds and It’s Already Street Legal

RML’s VarEVolt battery is blazing a trail for ultra-fast EV charging and hypercar performance.

DARPA Just Beamed Power Over 5 Miles Using Lasers and Used It To Make Popcorn

A record-breaking laser beam could redefine how we send power to the world's hardest places.

Why Do Some Birds Sing More at Dawn? It's More About Social Behavior Than The Environment

Study suggests birdsong patterns are driven more by social needs than acoustics.

Nonproducing Oil Wells May Be Emitting 7 Times More Methane Than We Thought

A study measured methane flow from more than 450 nonproducing wells across Canada, but thousands more remain unevaluated.

CAR T Breakthrough Therapy Doubles Survival Time for Deadly Stomach Cancer

Scientists finally figured out a way to take CAR-T cell therapy beyond blood.

The Sun Will Annihilate Earth in 5 Billion Years But Life Could Move to Jupiter's Icy Moon Europa

When the Sun turns into a Red Giant, Europa could be life's final hope in the solar system.

Ancient Roman ‘Fast Food’ Joint Served Fried Wild Songbirds to the Masses

Archaeologists uncover thrush bones in a Roman taberna, challenging elite-only food myths

A Man Lost His Voice to ALS. A Brain Implant Helped Him Sing Again

It's a stunning breakthrough for neuroprosthetics

This Plastic Dissolves in Seawater and Leaves Behind Zero Microplastics

Japanese scientists unveil a material that dissolves in hours in contact with salt, leaving no trace behind.

Women Rate Women’s Looks Higher Than Even Men

Across cultures, both sexes find female faces more attractive—especially women.