homehome Home chatchat Notifications


First remdesivir results aren't too promising, but things are far from clear

Antiviral drug touted as potential COVID-19 treatment is not doing too well, according to inadvertently released results.

Mihai Andrei
April 28, 2020 @ 1:10 am

share Share

The good news is that results from the first official findings from the randomized trial of the antiviral drug remdesivir could come out earlier than anticipated, in the first weeks of May. The bad news is that the results might not be all we hoped for.

Remdesivir was first trialed against Ebola a few years ago, but it didn’t seem to go as well as was hoped for. The antiviral treatment recently gained a lot of attention as a potential treatment for COVID-19, with some promising preliminary results.

For instance, doctors at Houston Methodist Hospital told Reuters that since March 23, they have treated 41 mostly severely ill COVID-19 patients with the drug. None have died and half are back home. But this was not done in a clinical setting and therefore it’s impossible to know how much of this positive effect was owed to the drug itself, and how much was accounted for by other factors.

Several other hospitals shared similar data, and in early April 2020, remdesivir was viewed as the most promising potential treatment for COVID-19 by Johns Hopkins University. But things don’t look so good now.

The first negative data came with a draft published “by mistake” on the World Health Organization website summary. This was picked up by the media, who saved a screenshot of the study. The presented summary said the Chinese trial involved 237 patients, with 158 on the drug and 79 in a control group. Remdesivir was stopped early in 18 patients because of side effects. After a month, 13.9 percent of the patients on remdesivir had died compared to 12.8 percent of those in the control group — a difference too small to be considered statistically significant.

However, Gilead (the company manufacturing remdesivir) said that negative characterization of the media is unwarranted.

“We believe the post included inappropriate characterizations of the study,” saying it was terminated early due to low enrollment and was therefore not statistically meaningful.

“As such, the study results are inconclusive, though trends in the data suggest a potential benefit for remdesivir, particularly among patients treated early in disease,” the spokesman added.

For now, it’s pretty unclear just how much potential remdesivir has, but there are already several large-scale trials ongoing, and a few are already in advanced stages. This means that in the not-too-distant-future, we could get a much clearer picture.

For instance, a very rigorous study supported by the NIH is set for publication in May. This is a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, which means that the study compares patients who received remdesivir to those who didn’t, and neither the doctors nor the patients know who is getting the real drug and who is getting a placebo (to avoid all possible biases).

The study, which features patients from all around the world, progressed faster than expected and enrolled more patients than initially planned.

Dr. Andre Kalil, principal investigator for the trial, said he wants to see results that show “meaningful clinical benefits” for patients.

share Share

He Let Snakes Bite Him Over 200 Times and Now Scientists Want His Blood for an Universal Antivenom

A universal snakebite treatment may be within reach, thanks to an unlikely human experiment.

These companies want to make hand bags out of T-rex leather. But scientists aren't buying it

A lab-grown leather inspired by dinosaur skin sparks excitement—and scientific skepticism

This car-sized "millipede" was built like a tank — and had the face to go with it

A Carboniferous beast is showing its face.

Climate Change Is Breaking the Insurance Industry

Climate related problems, from storms to health issues, are causing a wave of change in the insurance industry.

9 Environmental Stories That Don't Get as Much Coverage as They Should

From whales to soil microbes, our planet’s living systems are fraying in silence.

Scientists Find CBD in a Common Brazilian Shrub That's Not Cannabis

This wild plant grows across South America and contains CBD.

Spruce Trees Are Like Real-Life Ents That Anticipate Solar Eclipse Hours in Advance and Sync Up

Trees sync their bioelectric signals like they're talking to each other.

The Haast's Eagle: The Largest Known Eagle Hunted Prey Fifteen Times Its Size

The extinct bird was so powerful it could kill a 400-pound animal with its talons.

Miracle surgery: Doctors remove a hard-to-reach spinal tumor through the eye of a patient

For the first time, a deadly spinal tumor has been removed via the eye socket route.

A Lawyer Put a Cartoon Dragon Watermark on Every Page of a Court Filing and The Judge Was Not Amused

A Michigan judge rebukes lawyer for filing documents with cartoon dragon watermark