homehome Home chatchat Notifications


How patients from the second coronavirus wave compare to those in the first wave

Doctors at a hospital in Houston, Texas, have published results comparing the patients from the first coronavirus surge (March-May) to the second one (May-July), connected to the lockdown relaxation. There’s a very strong argument against the idea that there even is a second wave in the US — the first one never actually ended. But […]

Mihai Andrei
August 17, 2020 @ 10:21 pm

share Share

Doctors at a hospital in Houston, Texas, have published results comparing the patients from the first coronavirus surge (March-May) to the second one (May-July), connected to the lockdown relaxation.

Researchers report better outcomes, but also shifting demographics in the second surge. Outbreaks are still very concerning and overall, the outcomes are concerning.

There’s a very strong argument against the idea that there even is a second wave in the US — the first one never actually ended. But regardless of what you may call it, this second surge is different in a number of ways. Here are some of the key differences, according to results published by researchers about the COVID-19 hospitalizations at the Methodist Hospital in Houston, Texas.

The presented results cover 774 and 2130 patients during surge 1 and 2, respectively. Here are some of the key differences and what they mean.

Demographics

Second surge patients were younger, but not by much

Patients in surge 2 were younger — mean age 57.3 vs 59.9 years, compared to the first surge. This is significant, but not nearly sufficient to explain the outcomes (as we will see).

The second wave hit minorities harder

Minorities weren’t the first group to be hit hard by the pandemic. But as things progressed, it became clearer and clearer that they are disproportionately affected by outbreaks. As of the 2010 U.S. Census, Hispanics and Latinos of any race were 38.2% of the state’s population.

Second surge patients were less affluent

It’s not just the racial disparity — the economic disparity also showed up in the second wave. People with a lower income may find it harder to socially distance or work from home. Overall, there was a significant demographic shift in the second surge.

Hospitalization data

We’re getting better at treating the disease, but the virus remains extremely dangerous even so.

Lower length of hospital stay

The first positive index in the second surge is the length of hospital stay, which was shortened from 7.1 to 4.8 days.

Mortality rates

Perhaps the biggest improvement was observed in mortality data — which was more than halved in the second surge.

ICU admission rate

The ICU admission was also lower.

What this all means

The Methodist Hospital in Houston, Texas, is a microcosm of many places in the US. It’s not representative of all places, but it offers a fairly good comparison of the first and second stages.

For starters, there’s a noted demographic shift. As expected, the disease is already disproportionately affecting minorities and the underprivileged — a shift that could further accentuate in the future. Researchers note that in the second surge there were more tests carried out, but the positivity rates were also higher, so the higher hospital census reflects the higher rates of disease prevalence.

Another important takeaway is that in the second surge, there were better outcome rates. This is partly caused by the fact that patients were slightly younger on average and had fewer comorbidities, but also because the treatment and monitoring approach has improved. Researchers also note that the second surge patients were much more likely to be treated with remdesivir, which has been shown to reduce hospitalization time and improve outcomes significantly.

“Surge 2 data indicated a demographic shift of the pandemic toward a younger, predominantly Hispanic, and lower socioeconomic patient population with an overall lower comorbidity burden, ICU admission rate, and in-hospital mortality, the researchers note in the study.”

“The overall better outcomes during surge 2 may be explained by a combination of lower comorbidity burden, lesser disease severity, and better medical management,” the researchers conclude.

The study “Characteristics and Outcomes of COVID-19 Patients During Initial Peak and Resurgence in the Houston Metropolitan Area” has been published in JAMA.

share Share

When Ice Gets Bent, It Sparks: A Surprising Source of Electricity in Nature’s Coldest Corners

Ice isn't as passive as it looks.

We can still easily get AI to say all sorts of dangerous things

Jailbreaking an AI is still an easy task.

Scientists Solved a Key Mystery Regarding the Evolution of Life on Earth

A new study brings scientists closer to uncovering how life began on Earth.

AI has a hidden water cost − here’s how to calculate yours

Artificial intelligence systems are thirsty, consuming as much as 500 milliliters of water – a single-serving water bottle – for each short conversation a user has with the GPT-3 version of OpenAI’s ChatGPT system. They use roughly the same amount of water to draft a 100-word email message. That figure includes the water used to […]

Smart Locks Have Become the Modern Frontier of Home Security

What happens when humanity’s oldest symbol of security—the lock—meets the Internet of Things?

A Global Study Shows Women Are Just as Aggressive as Men with Siblings

Girls are just as aggressive as boys — when it comes to their brothers and sisters.

Birds Are Singing Nearly An Hour Longer Every Day Because Of City Lights

Light pollution is making birds sing nearly an hour longer each day

U.S. Mine Waste Contains Enough Critical Minerals and Rare Earths to Easily End Imports. But Tapping into These Resources Is Anything but Easy

The rocks we discard hold the clean energy minerals we need most.

Scientists Master the Process For Better Chocolate and It’s Not in the Beans

Researchers finally control the fermentation process that can make or break chocolate.

Most Countries in the World Were Ready for a Historic Plastic Agreement. Oil Giants Killed It

Diplomats from 184 nations packed their bags with no deal and no clear path forward.