homehome Home chatchat Notifications


A Fossil So Strange Scientists Think It’s From a Completely New Form of Life

This towering mystery fossil baffled scientists for 180 Years and it just got weirder.

Tibi Puiu
April 1, 2025 @ 2:49 am

share Share

Illustration of what Prototaxites might have looked like.

Millions of years before the first trees grew their canopies and the earliest insects buzzed, a strange organism sprouted from the ground. It looked like a trunk, cylindrical and bare, stretching over 20 feet into the Devonian sky. But it had no leaves. No branches. No clear kin. For nearly two centuries, paleontologists argued about what this bizarre life-form was.

Now, new research suggests Prototaxites — long thought to be a colossal fungus — may have belonged to a completely unknown chapter in the story of life on Earth. Not a plant, not an animal, and not a fungus — but something entirely different.

A Branch with No Tree

The fossil record first met Prototaxites in 1843, buried in ancient rocks that hinted at some enormous tree. Due to its vast size — up to 26 feet tall and 3 feet wide — it was first mistaken for the remains of rotting conifer trunks. But that suspicion crumbled once scientists realized conifers didn’t yet exist when Prototaxites flourished, between 420 and 375 million years ago. The first trees appeared around 350 million years ago.

In 2007, a team led by Stanford geobiologist Kevin Boyce found that carbon isotopes in the fossils resembled those of fungi — not plants. The chemical data suggested that Prototaxites absorbed carbon from other organisms rather than using photosynthesis. This is a hallmark of fungal life. So, at the time, it seemed the mystery had been solved.

Illustration of Prototaxites. Credit: National Museum of Natural History.

However, a new study led by paleobiologist Corentin Loron at the University of Edinburgh has flipped the script once again. Using preserved fossils from a site in Aberdeenshire, Scotland — the famed Rhynie chert (a Lower Devonian sedimentary deposit) — Loron and his colleagues examined a smaller species known as Prototaxites taiti. Though only a few inches tall, its internal structures were intact enough to dissect in detail.

What they found was deeply peculiar.

Not Fungi Either

Under the microscope, P. taiti showed an elaborate network of tubes — a feature fungi are known for. But the resemblance stopped there. These tubes curved, branched, and looped in ways not seen in any modern fungi. Some were thick-walled and unbranched, others thin and highly branched. Some bore faint rings — growth patterns fungi don’t typically show.

Even more striking was its chemistry. The fossil left no trace of chitin, the tough sugar compound found in the cell walls of all fungi. Instead, its molecular signature resembled lignin — a polymer found in woody plants — though it was still chemically distinct from anything botanists have cataloged. This difference was made clearer by comparing Prototaxites with bona fide fossil fungi found in the same rock layer. The fungi bore unmistakable signs of chitin. Prototaxites did not.

“Having found no support for the most widely held view that Prototaxites was fungal, we next reviewed possible placement in other higher taxonomic groups. No extant group was found to exhibit all the defining features of Prototaxites,” the team wrote in their paper, for now posted on the preprint server bioRxiv.

The scientists conclude that Prototaxites likely belonged to “a previously undescribed, entirely extinct group of eukaryotes.”

In the grand tree of life, that’s a big claim. Eukaryotes — organisms with complex cells — include animals, plants, fungi, and protists. But this ancient tree-like giant, the researchers argue, fits in none of these categories. It stands apart.

Before Trees and Insects

The notion that Prototaxites was not a fungus but an unknown branch of life has stirred intrigue and, inevitably, some skepticism.

“The assumption that it was likely to be in the fungi was somewhat nebulous, particularly given the nature of the fossils, and seemed somewhat counterintuitive given the relatively massive size,” Brett Summerell, a fungus expert at the Botanic Gardens of Sydney, told New Scientist. “The conclusion that it is a completely unknown eukaryote certainly creates an air of mystery and intrigue around it — probably not likely to be solved until more fossils are discovered or new analytical techniques developed.”

A new kingdom of life unknown to science wouldn’t be out of question. Nature has experimented wildly throughout Earth’s history. Many ancient lineages have disappeared without leaving living descendants. The Ediacaran biota, for example, vanished 540 million years ago after a short, enigmatic reign — leaving no descendants behind.

Kevin Boyce believes the organism may have been “a novel experiment with complex multicellularity that is now extinct.” It may not have photosynthesized like a plant. It didn’t decompose like a mushroom. And it certainly didn’t walk, swim, or crawl. But it grew. It fed. It thrived for tens of millions of years. Then it vanished.

Why Prototaxites disappeared could be explained by a number of different things. Perhaps it was outcompeted by newly evolving land plants and fungi. As early shrubs and trees colonized Earth’s surface, the towering structures of Prototaxites may have lost their ecological niche.

These mysteries and more might be solved with new findings in the future.

share Share

The Universe’s First “Little Red Dots” May Be a New Kind of Star With a Black Hole Inside

Mysterious red dots may be a peculiar cosmic hybrid between a star and a black hole.

Peacock Feathers Can Turn Into Biological Lasers and Scientists Are Amazed

Peacock tail feathers infused with dye emit laser light under pulsed illumination.

Helsinki went a full year without a traffic death. How did they do it?

Nordic capitals keep showing how we can eliminate traffic fatalities.

Scientists Find Hidden Clues in The Alexander Mosaic. Its 2 Million Tiny Stones Came From All Over the Ancient World

One of the most famous artworks of the ancient world reads almost like a map of the Roman Empire's power.

Ancient bling: Romans May Have Worn a 450-Million-Year-Old Sea Fossil as a Pendant

Before fossils were science, they were symbols of magic, mystery, and power.

These wolves in Alaska ate all the deer. Then, they did something unexpected

Wolves on an Alaskan island are showing a remarkable adaptation.

This AI Therapy App Told a Suicidal User How to Die While Trying to Mimic Empathy

You really shouldn't use a chatbot for therapy.

This New Coating Repels Oil Like Teflon Without the Nasty PFAs

An ultra-thin coating mimics Teflon’s performance—minus most of its toxicity.

Why You Should Stop Using Scented Candles—For Good

They're seriously not good for you.

People in Thailand were chewing psychoactive nuts 4,000 years ago. It's in their teeth

The teeth Chico, they never lie.