homehome Home chatchat Notifications


NASA and amateur space enthusiast find lost Indian moon lander

Parts from the craft landed in almost two dozen locations spanning several kilometers.

Alexandru Micu
December 3, 2019 @ 5:33 pm

share Share

NASA, with some vital help from a space enthusiast, has found India’s Vikram lander, which was lost on its final approach to the Moon.

NASA image taken by the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter showing the impact site of the Vikram lander.
Image credits NASA.

Back in September, the Vikram lander was close to landing on the Moon — and then it disappeared. However, the mystery was solved. In an announcement on Monday, NASA released an image taken by the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) showing the final impact site of the spacecraft. The find was made possible thanks to the efforts of one amateur space enthusiast.

Shoot for the Moon

“It was quite hard, but (I) spent some effort,” Shanmuga “Shan” Subramanian, a 33-year-old IT professional from Chennai and self-professed space nerd who found the lander.

“I had side-by-side comparison of those two images on two of my laptops. On one side there was the old image, and another side there was the new image released by NASA,” he said, adding he was helped by fellow Twitter and Reddit users.

Back on September 26, NASA released a mosaic image of the site where the lander was believed to have crashed, inviting the public to compare them with images of the same site taken before the lander’s crash. Subramanian was the first to spot the craft. In an interview with AFP, he explained that it was NASA’s inability to find the lander that sparked his interest.

NASA checked Subramanian’s findings by performing additional scans of the area and officially announced the news on Monday, some two months later. A version of the picture mosaic picture, one marked up to show the debris field generated by the crash, was released with the announcement. Parts from the craft landed in almost two dozen locations spanning several kilometers.

“NASA has to be 100% sure before they can go public, and that’s the reason they waited to confirm it, and even I would have done the same,” said Subramanian.

India launched the Chandrayaan-2 (“Moon Vehicle 2”) lander back in July, aiming to become the fourth country to make a successful Moon landing after the United States, Russia, and China; the vehicle was also intended to be the first one to even touch down on the lunar south pole.

The mission consisted of a main spacecraft that would stay in orbit around the Moon and drop the unmanned lander Vikram onto its surface. The drop was estimated to take five days, and everything went pretty swimmingly until ground control lost contact with Vikram went silent just 2.1 kilometers above the surface.

share Share

China Now Uses 80% Artificial Sand. Here's Why That's A Bigger Deal Than It Sounds

No need to disturb water bodies for sand. We can manufacture it using rocks or mining waste — China is already doing it.

Over 2,250 Environmental Defenders Have Been Killed or Disappeared in the Last 12 Years

The latest tally from Global Witness is a grim ledger. In 2024, at least 146 people were killed or disappeared while defending land, water and forests. That brings the total to at least 2,253 deaths and disappearances since 2012, a steady toll that turns local acts of stewardship into mortal hazards. The organization’s report reads less like […]

After Charlie Kirk’s Murder, Americans Are Asking If Civil Discourse Is Even Possible Anymore

Trying to change someone’s mind can seem futile. But there are approaches to political discourse that still matter, even if they don’t instantly win someone over.

Climate Change May Have Killed More Than 16,000 People in Europe This Summer

Researchers warn that preventable heat-related deaths will continue to rise with continued fossil fuel emissions.

New research shows how Trump uses "strategic victimhood" to justify his politics

How victimhood rhetoric helped Donald Trump justify a sweeping global trade war

Biggest Modern Excavation in Tower of London Unearths the Stories of the Forgotten Inhabitants

As the dig deeper under the Tower of London they are unearthing as much history as stone.

Millions Of Users Are Turning To AI Jesus For Guidance And Experts Warn It Could Be Dangerous

AI chatbots posing as Jesus raise questions about profit, theology, and manipulation.

Can Giant Airbags Make Plane Crashes Survivable? Two Engineers Think So

Two young inventors designed an AI-powered system to cocoon planes before impact.

First Food to Boost Immunity: Why Blueberries Could Be Your Baby’s Best First Bite

Blueberries have the potential to give a sweet head start to your baby’s gut and immunity.

Ice Age People Used 32 Repeating Symbols in Caves Across the World. They May Reveal the First Steps Toward Writing

These simple dots and zigzags from 40,000 years ago may have been the world’s first symbols.