homehome Home chatchat Notifications


Last December, California's water became a commodity on the stock market

This may make some investors happy, but it spells trouble for the environment.

Alexandru Micu
January 6, 2021 @ 4:09 pm

share Share

As the world’s climate shifts, the shape of our future becomes more and more uncertain. However, Wall Street is poised to make a profit out of this uncertainty, by allowing water to be traded just like any other commodity.

The ‘water market’ — the first of its kind in the world — launched last month on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, according to Bloomberg News. All in all, it opened at roughly $1.1 billion in contracts tied to water prices in California.

Trading water

“Climate change, droughts, population growth, and pollution are likely to make water scarcity issues and pricing a hot topic for years to come,” RBC Capital Markets managing director and analyst Deane Dray told Bloomberg.

“We are definitely going to watch how this new water futures contract develops.”

Such a market would allow anyone to bet on the future price of water and its availability in the Western US by buying shares. It was opened largely due to the massive wildfires that have swept the country last year, and the rising temperatures and drought levels associated with it and climate change, as water has become more and more a scarce commodity.

The question, as always, remains — is this a good thing? On the one hand such markets can do a surprisingly effective job at keeping prices and supply stable; nobody wants to lose their money, after all. The hope is that traders will give officials a better idea of the actual price of water in the future, allowing them to get the best deals and ensure that the people have access to water no matter what happens.

But on the other hand, nobody wants to lose their money, which can become a problem when we’re talking basic essentials such as water. Trading could promote a competitive mindset where profit, not proper public access and availability, becomes the name of the game. The economy can often thrive at the expense of the environment, and treating water as a tradeable commodity can quickly become a slippery slope, especially as water security is viewed as one of the largest hurdles we’ll have to overcome in the future. Climate change is also going to make matters worse, as it affects precipitation patterns and promotes drought.

“What this represents is a cynical attempt at setting up what’s almost like a betting casino so some people can make money from others suffering,” said Basav Sen, climate justice project director at the Institute for Policy Studies, for LA Times.

“My first reaction when I saw this was horror, but we’ve also seen this coming for quite some time.”

Is this a sign for what’s to come the world over? Right now, we don’t know — it could very well be. California finds itself in a pretty unique setting. The state is relatively dry but well populated, rich, and has strong industrial and agricultural sectors. All of this leads to sizeable competition for water at affordable prices between household users, economic actors, and (especially in the wake of the wildfires) environmental needs.

It is hoped that the implementation of the water market will lead to lower prices and a better distribution of the vital resource. Time will tell if this is a good idea, or not.

share Share

A small, portable test could revolutionize how we diagnose Alzheimer's

A passive EEG scan could spot memory loss before symptoms begin to show.

2.2 Million Fat-Removal Surgeries a Year: What's Behind the Body Contouring Boom

From liposuction to cryolipolysis, fat-removal is now one of the most common cosmetic choices worldwide.

Labiaplasty Is the Fastest-Growing Cosmetic Surgery Worldwide — And It’s Not Just About Looks

Once a taboo subject, vaginal rejuvenation is now part of a broader conversation about women’s intimate wellness.

Ultra-Processed Foods Made Healthy Young Men Gain Fat and Lose Sperm Quality in Just Three Weeks

Processed foods harmed hormones and fertility markers even with identical calories.

Could AI and venom help us fight antibiotic resistance?

Scientists used AI to mine animal venom for potent new antibiotics.

Scientists Reprogram Blood Cells to Prevent Alzheimer’s and Fight Aging In the Brain

In a promising new study, modified young immune cells improved brain performance in older mice.

America’s Sex Ed System Is An Anti-Science Nightmare

Only 37% of US states require sex ed to be medically accurate.

Doctors with More Patient Complaints Also More Likely to Take Industry Money, Study Finds

There seems to be a concerning link between patient complaints and industry payouts.

A Daily Pill Helped Obesity Patients Lose Over 10 Kilograms in Major Trial, But Injectibles Are Still Slightly Better

The pill matches injections in effectiveness, offering a needle-free option for millions

Scientists Transplant Pig Lung Into Human for the First Time. It Worked for Nine Days

Genetically engineered lung functioned for nine days, marking a tentative step for xenotransplantation.