homehome Home chatchat Notifications


Google says it will delete abortion clinic visits from users' history -- and it's really sad they have to do this

It's a twisted world when companies move in to protect people's rights from the state, but here we are.

Mihai Andrei
July 4, 2022 @ 12:18 pm

share Share

Google says the move is not just for abortion clinics, but will also remove location data from people’s visits to other sensitive locations. The company also emphasized its history of “pushing back” against over-reaching law enforcement demands, hinting again at abortion but without clearly referring to it.

With the US Supreme Court overturning Roe v Wade, access to safe abortion vanished almost overnight for millions of Americans. Already, the unfortunate consequences of the decision became visible when a 10-year-old child rape victim was forced to travel to a different state to get an abortion — and we’re only starting.

Abortion providers in states where this is still legal say they’re receiving a sharp increase in the number of patients coming from neighboring states where the practice is now banned. With many US states reverting to century-old abortion laws, there are concerns that states may even ban traveling to another state to get an abortion or may start seeking personal information of the people who have sought or facilitated abortions.

With people’s health information now becoming potentially weaponized, it puts tech companies who have access to this information in a delicate position. Google has now become the first big tech company to publicly say how it will handle such data.

“Some of the places people visit — including medical facilities like counseling centers, domestic violence shelters, abortion clinics, fertility centers, addiction treatment facilities, weight loss clinics, cosmetic surgery clinics, and others — can be particularly personal,” says Google’s senior vice president Jen Fitzpatrick wrote in a company blog post. “Today, we’re announcing that if our systems identify that someone has visited one of these places, we will delete these entries from Location History soon after they visit. This change will take effect in the coming weeks.”

This decision could turn out to be very consequential. Already, in at least two states, authorities have used search history information to prosecute women for abortion. While sensitive search data will likely stay stored, people’s travel locations will be deleted — though it’s not exactly clear what “soon” means. Google also reiterated that the location history of a Google account is off by default.

The company also hinted that it will resist state requests for user data, despite not mentioning abortion directly.

“Google has a long track record of pushing back on overly broad demands from law enforcement, including objecting to some demands entirely. We take into account the privacy and security expectations of people using our products, and we notify people when we comply with government demands, unless we’re prohibited from doing so or lives are at stake — such as in an emergency situation.”

Google also mentioned that they will also address other services that can be linked to abortion (such as Fitbits, for instance). Users can register menstrual data in Fitbits, which can be used to make deductions about a potential abortion.

“Fitbit users who have chosen to track their menstrual cycles in the app can currently delete menstruation logs one at a time, and we will be rolling out updates that let users delete multiple logs at once,” Google’s Fitzpatrick says.

In a separate update, Google said it will also designate US advertisers that dispense pills by mail after a virtual consultation as “providing abortions.” This is because, in order to be allowed to run ads for abortion on Google, you first have to apply for a certification. Now, providers that dispense pills via mail will be allowed to get that certification.

The announcements made by Google come amid escalating pressure on big tech companies to do more to shield sensitive data about their users, protecting the data not just from other companies, but also from government authorities. In May, a group of 42 Democratic lawmakers urged Google CEO Sundar Pichai in a letter to stop collecting and keeping location data that could be used to identify people seeking abortions.

However, while Google’s decision is bound to be influential and significant, it won’t do very much on its own. The company seemed to concede that much, saying that ensuring people’s privacy is a shared responsibility.

“Given that these issues apply to healthcare providers, telecommunications companies, banks, tech platforms, and many more, we know privacy protections cannot be solely up to individual companies or states acting individually,” the post said.

Overturning Roe will come with severe consequences. A string of legal battles is bound to begin, as the US is battling with the complex decisions that emerge in a post-Roe world. Tech companies will undoubtedly have a role to play in this, but when we rely on companies to protect us from the government, it’s not a good sign.

share Share

Archaeologists May Have Found Odysseus’ Sanctuary on Ithaca

A new discovery ties myth to place, revealing centuries of cult worship and civic ritual.

The World’s Largest Sand Battery Just Went Online in Finland. It could change renewable energy

This sand battery system can store 1,000 megawatt-hours of heat for weeks at a time.

A Hidden Staircase in a French Church Just Led Archaeologists Into the Middle Ages

They pulled up a church floor and found a staircase that led to 1500 years of history.

The World’s Largest Camera Is About to Change Astronomy Forever

A new telescope camera promises a 10-year, 3.2-billion-pixel journey through the southern sky.

AI 'Reanimated' a Murder Victim Back to Life to Speak in Court (And Raises Ethical Quandaries)

AI avatars of dead people are teaching courses and testifying in court. Even with the best of intentions, the emerging practice of AI ‘reanimations’ is an ethical quagmire.

This Rare Viking Burial of a Woman and Her Dog Shows That Grief and Love Haven’t Changed in a Thousand Years

The power of loyalty, in this life and the next.

This EV Battery Charges in 18 Seconds and It’s Already Street Legal

RML’s VarEVolt battery is blazing a trail for ultra-fast EV charging and hypercar performance.

This new blood test could find cancerous tumors three years before any symptoms

Imagine catching cancer before symptoms even appear. New research shows we’re closer than ever.

DARPA Just Beamed Power Over 5 Miles Using Lasers and Used It To Make Popcorn

A record-breaking laser beam could redefine how we send power to the world's hardest places.

Why Do Some Birds Sing More at Dawn? It's More About Social Behavior Than The Environment

Study suggests birdsong patterns are driven more by social needs than acoustics.