homehome Home chatchat Notifications


A plea from Italian doctors: to avoid disaster, treat more patients at home

The lessons from Italy are vital for the rest of the world, as we brace for an influx of COVID-19 infections.

Mihai Andrei
March 23, 2020 @ 5:02 pm

share Share

The heartbreaking reports from Italy come as a sobering reality check: Italy is not the worst-case scenario, it is the scenario most countries will have to face. We need to change our perspective to avoid a disaster, Italian doctors warn.

Bergamo’s tragedy might become the world’s tragedy unless serious action is taken soon. Image via Wikipedia.

A dozen physicians in the city of Bergamo in Lombardia, Italy, have published a plea for the rest of the world: patient-centered care is inadequate in a global pandemic and must be complemented by community-centered care.

The report starts off with a heartbreaking recollection of the situation in Bergamo.

“The situation here is dismal as we operate well below our normal standard of care. Wait times for an intensive care bed are hours long. Older patients are not being resuscitated,” they add.

Faced with limited resources, doctors in Italy (and already in other countries) must make dramatic decisions. They decide who gets one of the limited ICU beds, and who does not — a decision no doctor should ever have to make.

The experience of Bergamo doctors can also be very useful for physicians in other parts of the world to better prepare for the situation. “Some of the mistakes that happened in Italy can happen here,” said Maurizio Cereda, co-director of the surgical ICU at Penn Medicine and a co-author of the paper. Cereda and colleagues hope that physicians and policymakers will heed the warnings.

The US medical system, like that in Europe and most parts of the world, is centralized and hospital-focused. This makes an excellent environment for the virus to spread inside the hospital, and putting other patients at risk of infection is something that must be avoided.

“We need dedicated Covid-19 hospital pavilions and operators, separated from virus-free areas,” the Italian medics continue. “In hospitals, protection of medical personnel should be prioritized. No compromise should be made on protocols; equipment must be available. Measures to prevent infection must be implemented massively, in all locations and including vehicles.”

The change they are referring to in particular is home treatment. Home care and mobile clinics can avoid unnecessary movements and release pressure from hospitals, offering a much-needed breath of air.

“This approach would limit hospitalization to a focused target of disease severity, thereby decreasing contagion, protecting patients and health care workers, and minimizing consumption of protective equipment,” the researchers explain.

This would require the deployment of mobile clinics, as well as home visits. Some treatment and monitoring could be delivered to the homes of patients with non-severe symptoms, setting up a broad surveillance system, leveraging innovative telemedicine instruments, researchers say.

Medical home visits might seem like an idea from a long-gone era, but it’s this type of solution we must look towards to stave off the damage coming from the novel coronavirus.

It requires a shift in perspective, and it requires an understanding that this crisis will require community solutions.

“This outbreak is more than an intensive care phenomenon, rather it is a public health and humanitarian crisis. We urgently need humanitarian agencies who recognize the importance of local engagement,” the researchers add.

As hospitals are “nearing collapse” in resource-rich Lombardy, solutions such as these are not only worth considering — they might be paramount in the upcoming battle with the outbreak.

The researchers also draw attention to the fact that this will be a drawn-out challenge, and no country is free of problems just yet — suppression is merely the first step.

“Lockdown is paramount: social distancing reduced transmission by about 60% in China. But a further peak will likely occur when restrictive measures are relaxed to avoid major economic impact.”

share Share

More Than Half of Intersection Crashes Involve Left Turns. Is It Time To Finally Ban Them?

Even though research supports the change, most cities have been slow to ban left turns at even the most congested intersections.

A London Dentist Just Cracked a Geometric Code in Leonardo’s Vitruvian Man

A hidden triangle in the vitruvian man could finally explain one of da Vinci's greatest works.

The Story Behind This Female Pharaoh's Broken Statues Is Way Weirder Than We Thought

New study reveals the ancient Egyptian's odd way of retiring a pharaoh.

China Resurrected an Abandoned Soviet 'Sea Monster' That's Part Airplane, Part Hovercraft

The Soviet Union's wildest aircraft just got a second life in China.

A Rocket Carried Cannabis Seeds and 166 Human Remains into Space But Their Capsule Never Made It Back

The spacecraft crashed into the Pacific Ocean after a parachute failure, ending a bold experiment in space biology and memorial spaceflight.

Ancient ‘Zombie’ Fungus Trapped in Amber Shows Mind Control Began in the Age of the Dinosaurs

The zombie fungus from the age of the dinosaurs.

Your browser lets websites track you even without cookies

Most users don't even know this type of surveillance exists.

Ozempic Users Are Seeing a Surprising Drop in Alcohol and Drug Cravings

Diabetes drugs show surprising promise in reducing alcohol and opioid use

What's Seasonal Body Image Dissatisfaction and How Not to Fall into Its Trap

This season doesn’t have to be about comparison or self-criticism.

Why a 20-Minute Nap Could Be Key to Unlocking 'Eureka!' Moments Like Salvador Dalí

A 20-minute nap can boost your chances of a creative breakthrough, according to new research.