homehome Home chatchat Notifications


Earth is no longer a 'safe operating space for humanity.' Climate change isn't even the biggest problem

Study looks into the planetary boundaries and how we are affecting them

Fermin Koop
September 15, 2023 @ 12:12 pm

share Share

Human activities are causing dramatic effects on Earth’s environmental conditions. From logging to plastic pollution to greenhouse gas emissions, we’re changing the living conditions on the planet. These actions, if unchecked, might result in an Earth unsuitable to sustain our current way of life. In fact, a sobering new study suggests that we may already be in the danger zone.

Image credits: Stockholm Resilience Center.

The study builds on a paper from 2009 that outlined nine planetary boundaries. Basically, if we start crossing these boundaries, humanity is in trouble. These are:

  • biosphere integrity;
  • climate change;
  • freshwater changes;
  • ocean acidification;
  • ozone depletion;
  • land use change;
  • introduction of novel entities (pollution);
  • biogeochemical flows;
  • and aerosol loading.

All of these have been transgressed except three: ocean acidification, aerosol loading, and ozone depletion. In other words, we’re crossing most of the environmental planetary boundaries that keep life on Earth safe.

This means that Earth’s life support systems are being significantly disrupted. The stable conditions that have been around for about 10,000 years, and which usually only change in geological time, have started since the shifting Industrial Revolution.

This doesn’t mean impending doom, researchers say. But it does show we’re headed for trouble.

“We can think of Earth as a human body, and the planetary boundaries as blood pressure. Over 120/80 does not indicate a certain heart attack but it does raise the risk and, therefore, we work to reduce blood pressure,” Katherine Richardson, lead author and oceanography professor at the University of Copenhagen, said in a news release.

The planetary boundaries

Climate change is one of the most evident breaches of the planetary boundaries. The researchers looked at the concentration of carbon dioxide (CO2) – now at 417 parts per million (ppm), a big jump from the 280 ppm when the industrial revolution started. They set the safe threshold at 350 ppm, a mark that was exceeded back in 1987. To make matters even worse, our greenhouse gas emissions are accelerating.

But climate change isn’t even our worst transgression. Apparently, it’s how we treat life on Earth.

Biosphere integrity — essentially a market for how well different species and ecosystems are doing — is under grave threat. We’re destroying vast swaths of the natural world which is triggering high extinction rates. Experts agree we have now entered into a sixth mass extinction driven by human activity. About 40% of the land has already been converted for food production, recent reports show.

“Next to climate change, integrity of the biosphere is the second pillar of stability of our planet. Our research shows that mitigating global warming and saving a functional biosphere for the future have to go hand in hand,” Wolfgang Lucht, co-author and researcher at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, said in a news release.

Another big problem comes with phosphorus and nitrogen. These are extensively used as crop fertilizers to enhance performance and then run out into ecosystems, severely polluting them. The researchers found that humans are releasing more of these chemicals into the environment than the planetary limits that they calculated.

The study also looked at “novel entities” — meaning artificial chemicals released in the environment, such as plastic waste and forever chemicals (PFAS), which are becoming a big problem around the world. We have also crossed this boundary, meaning that we are releasing chemicals into the environment at a hazardous level.

“Our study shows that humans are appropriating the equivalent of 30% of the energy that was available to support biodiversity before the Industrial Revolution,” Katherine Richardson said in a news release. “Surely, the removal of so much of the energy that otherwise would have been available to nature must be a driver of biodiversity loss.”

Righting the course

The planetary boundaries are not irreversible tipping points, the researchers explained. It’s not like you can’t go back and improve things, at least not yet.

Crossing six boundaries, as we have done so far, does not necessarily imply a disaster but it’s a clear warning signal, the researchers said. In fact, we have one success story already. The fact that humans have been able to address and reduce ozone depletion, one of the nine boundaries that we haven’t crossed, shows humanity has the capacity to turn things around if we act fast.

Granted, turning things like pollution or climate change around is set to be much more difficult. But the study provides a “guide for action” to how we can return to sustainable limits, while also securing prosperity and equity. Researchers end by calling for a systemic effort to protect, recover and rebuild planetary resilience and said the international community should put more focus on the need to limit our impacts.

The study was published in the journal Science Advances.

share Share

China Now Uses 80% Artificial Sand. Here's Why That's A Bigger Deal Than It Sounds

No need to disturb water bodies for sand. We can manufacture it using rocks or mining waste — China is already doing it.

Over 2,250 Environmental Defenders Have Been Killed or Disappeared in the Last 12 Years

The latest tally from Global Witness is a grim ledger. In 2024, at least 146 people were killed or disappeared while defending land, water and forests. That brings the total to at least 2,253 deaths and disappearances since 2012, a steady toll that turns local acts of stewardship into mortal hazards. The organization’s report reads less like […]

After Charlie Kirk’s Murder, Americans Are Asking If Civil Discourse Is Even Possible Anymore

Trying to change someone’s mind can seem futile. But there are approaches to political discourse that still matter, even if they don’t instantly win someone over.

Climate Change May Have Killed More Than 16,000 People in Europe This Summer

Researchers warn that preventable heat-related deaths will continue to rise with continued fossil fuel emissions.

New research shows how Trump uses "strategic victimhood" to justify his politics

How victimhood rhetoric helped Donald Trump justify a sweeping global trade war

Biggest Modern Excavation in Tower of London Unearths the Stories of the Forgotten Inhabitants

As the dig deeper under the Tower of London they are unearthing as much history as stone.

Millions Of Users Are Turning To AI Jesus For Guidance And Experts Warn It Could Be Dangerous

AI chatbots posing as Jesus raise questions about profit, theology, and manipulation.

Can Giant Airbags Make Plane Crashes Survivable? Two Engineers Think So

Two young inventors designed an AI-powered system to cocoon planes before impact.

First Food to Boost Immunity: Why Blueberries Could Be Your Baby’s Best First Bite

Blueberries have the potential to give a sweet head start to your baby’s gut and immunity.

Ice Age People Used 32 Repeating Symbols in Caves Across the World. They May Reveal the First Steps Toward Writing

These simple dots and zigzags from 40,000 years ago may have been the world’s first symbols.