homehome Home chatchat Notifications


The one word that almost ruined climate negotiations

The agreement in Paris is not a cure for the world’s environmental problems, but it’s definitely more than a band-aid. It provides a framework on which to build future global and national efforts, but one word came close to ruining everything. Visibly exhausted, French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius cracked a smile – probably the first […]

Mihai Andrei
December 13, 2015 @ 4:00 pm

share Share

The agreement in Paris is not a cure for the world’s environmental problems, but it’s definitely more than a band-aid. It provides a framework on which to build future global and national efforts, but one word came close to ruining everything.

Visibly exhausted, French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius cracked a smile – probably the first one in days, as United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon seemed close to crying. Even Julie Bishop, known for not giving overt displays of sentimentality described it as a “historic moment.” But they, as many other negotiators, will take home not only the sweet success of a successful negotiation, but also many a crisis averted at the last moment. Perhaps the most notable such crisis, as noted by one of the negotiators, took place on the very last session of the negotiations. The final version of the draft read:

“Developed Parties [countries] shall continue taking the lead by undertaking economy-wide absolute emission reduction targets.”

The word “shall” was almost a game-breaker, because unlike the word “should”, it indicates direct legal responsibility, and ratifying such a thing is borderline impossible on a hostile US Senate riddled with climate change deniers. Nicaragua’s chief negotiator stepped in to ask some modifications of his own, and it was only after US Secretary of State John Kerry made a phone call to Nicaragua’s President Daniel Ortega that things called down. It was a very nervous 90 minutes, that could have brought the entire negotiations crashing down.

But for all the fine tuned diplomacy from both French representatives and John Kerry, the pact falls short in several aspects. It won’t solve all our problems, it may not even be what we need to actively reduce global greenhouse gases. It almost certainly isn’t ambitious enough, and it puts only a vague responsibility on developed countries – yet it’s the best we have. It’s the first, and therefore the best global climate pact in the history of the planet. We’ll stick by it, and we’ll improve it. We’ll do our best to help preserve the climate and limit our damage as much as possible. The power lies in our hands, just as it lies in our leaders’ hands.

share Share

Archaeologists May Have Found Odysseus’ Sanctuary on Ithaca

A new discovery ties myth to place, revealing centuries of cult worship and civic ritual.

The World’s Largest Sand Battery Just Went Online in Finland. It could change renewable energy

This sand battery system can store 1,000 megawatt-hours of heat for weeks at a time.

A Hidden Staircase in a French Church Just Led Archaeologists Into the Middle Ages

They pulled up a church floor and found a staircase that led to 1500 years of history.

The World’s Largest Camera Is About to Change Astronomy Forever

A new telescope camera promises a 10-year, 3.2-billion-pixel journey through the southern sky.

AI 'Reanimated' a Murder Victim Back to Life to Speak in Court (And Raises Ethical Quandaries)

AI avatars of dead people are teaching courses and testifying in court. Even with the best of intentions, the emerging practice of AI ‘reanimations’ is an ethical quagmire.

This Rare Viking Burial of a Woman and Her Dog Shows That Grief and Love Haven’t Changed in a Thousand Years

The power of loyalty, in this life and the next.

This EV Battery Charges in 18 Seconds and It’s Already Street Legal

RML’s VarEVolt battery is blazing a trail for ultra-fast EV charging and hypercar performance.

DARPA Just Beamed Power Over 5 Miles Using Lasers and Used It To Make Popcorn

A record-breaking laser beam could redefine how we send power to the world's hardest places.

Why Do Some Birds Sing More at Dawn? It's More About Social Behavior Than The Environment

Study suggests birdsong patterns are driven more by social needs than acoustics.

Nonproducing Oil Wells May Be Emitting 7 Times More Methane Than We Thought

A study measured methane flow from more than 450 nonproducing wells across Canada, but thousands more remain unevaluated.